BIM / BUDGETS
BIM and budget reconciliation
Two structures that differ by nature
Across the different phases of an industrial project, the building services models and the budget represented the work according to different criteria. In Revit, networks might be broken down into pipes, fittings, ducts, equipment, and other components. In the BOQ, those same scopes were organized into line items, each with its own descriptions, units, and measurement rules. The reconciliation process needed to explain the relationship between these structures. For example, an item measured by length required locating the relevant elements and checking their dimensions; one measured per unit required identifying the equipment or fittings that actually applied. A similar type code was not enough to decide that two records should be included in the same line item.
Defining what belongs in each comparison
Comparators were organized for disciplines and systems such as mechanical services, ventilation, fire protection, drainage, external services, and electrical installations. Before adding quantities, it was necessary to define the scope of each item and prevent an element from being counted twice because it appeared in different exports. The criteria considered the system, building, component class, dimensions, unit of measurement, and identifying relationships. When information was missing or the equivalence between the model and the schedule of items was uncertain, the case remained visible for review instead of being automatically assigned to the closest-looking item.
Contributing to matching decisions
My contribution involved providing and reviewing line-item information, taking part in decisions about which object groups should be compared, and examining results to detect associations that required technical interpretation. The comparators were developed in Python and retained, alongside the quantities, element references and the reason for each assignment. A consolidated output was then prepared, bringing together the results from the disciplines for the preconstruction team's review. The final sum had to respect assignments already made, without redistributing elements under a different rule during consolidation. This work made it possible to discuss discrepancies more precisely: which objects were included, which unit was used, how the total was calculated, and which cases needed to be reviewed with the estimating team. Reconciliation organized information to support decisions rather than hiding discrepancies to produce figures that only appeared to agree.